Ryan's District Gains Despite His Positions

Aug 16, 2012
Originally published on August 21, 2012 4:53 pm

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney's running mate, Paul Ryan, has staked out a reputation in Congress as a fiscal conservative. He has spoken out against President Obama's efforts to jump-start the economy with the stimulus law and, after a conversion a few years ago, now opposes earmarks. But when it comes to helping out his district in southern Wisconsin, Ryan's principles have been flexible.

Ryan was never a fan of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, as the stimulus is officially known. He voted against it when it came to the House floor in 2009, as did every other House Republican, and he railed against it in frequent TV appearances.

"Temporary stimulus does not work," he said on CNBC. "It does not give businesses confidence to invest in jobs and capital for the future. It's just sort of sugar-high economics."

But despite his denunciations of the measure, Ryan made sure his constituents were not left out when the money was divvied up. When the Energy Center of Wisconsin, a nonprofit that promotes energy-efficient buildings, sought Ryan's help in obtaining stimulus money, he came through.

Stimulus, TARP, Auto Bailout

"We asked the entire Wisconsin congressional delegation for support of several proposals that we were submitting under that funding, and Rep. Ryan did support a couple of the proposals that we submitted," said Leslie Post, a spokeswoman for the Energy Center.

The Energy Center received nearly $250,000 in stimulus money thanks in part to Ryan's efforts. The Wisconsin Energy Conservation Corp. did even better, receiving a $20 million grant for energy-efficiency projects.

There have been other occasions where Ryan has acted for his constituents in ways that might not please the most ardent Tea Party supporters. He voted for the auto industry bailout, which Romney opposed. Ryan's hometown, Janesville, Wis., was home to a since-shuttered GM plant. He also voted for the Troubled Asset Relief Program to rescue the financial industry, saying during House debate that though it violated his principles, it was necessary to prevent a banking crisis.

"Why does that matter to us? Why does that matter to Janesville, Wis.?" he asked at the time. "If it goes the way it could go, that means credit shuts down, businesses can't get money to pay their payroll to pay their employees, students can't get student loans for next semester, people can't get car loans, seniors may not have access to their savings."

Opposition To Earmarks

Ryan has also worked for his 1st District constituents in less public ways.

John Beckord, president of the economic development group Janesville Forward, says Ryan only has to be asked and he'll pick up the phone to help recruit a new company to the area.

"A call from Paul Ryan to a CEO of that company is, I think, most often accepted, and Paul at the very least, I think, can encourage that CEO to at least take a look," Beckord said

Beckord says Ryan helped Janesville land Shine Medical Technologies, a company that makes radioactive isotopes used to treat melanomas; the company is receiving a multimillion-dollar federal grant.

Still, some in Janesville wish Ryan would do more. Earlier in his congressional career, he delivered more than $5 million in earmarks to his district, according to Taxpayers for Common Sense. Ryan has since renounced the use of earmarks, though Beckord says not everyone agrees with that position.

"There are people in the community who wish someone with the stature of Congressman Ryan might help us get some earmarks for this or that," he said.

But Ryan has now convinced many in the 1st District that, as Beckord puts it, business as usual when it comes to earmarks is not a plan for the future.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

Republican Mitt Romney's running mate, Paul Ryan, has staked out a reputation in Congress as a fiscal conservative. He has spoken out against President Obama's efforts to jump-start the economy using stimulus money, and after a conversion a few years ago, Ryan now opposes earmarks - the cash members of Congress can secure for pet projects. But when it comes to helping out his own district in southern Wisconsin, Ryan's principles have been flexible. NPR's Brian Naylor has a look at the congressman's voting record.

BRIAN NAYLOR, BYLINE: Paul Ryan was never a fan of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, aka the stimulus. He voted against it when it came to the House floor in 2009, as did every other House Republican, and he railed against it in frequent TV appearances, such as this one on CNBC.

(SOUNDBITE OF CNBC BROADCAST)

PAUL RYAN: Temporary stimulus does not work. It does not give businesses confidence to invest in jobs and capital for the future. And it's just sort of sugar-high economics.

NAYLOR: But despite his denunciations of the measure, Ryan made sure that his constituents were not left out when the money was divvied up. When the Energy Center of Wisconsin - a nonprofit that promotes energy-efficient buildings - sought Ryan's help in obtaining stimulus money, Ryan came through. Here's the Energy Center's Leslie Post.

LESLIE POST: We asked the entire Wisconsin congressional delegation for support of several proposals that we were submitting under that funding, and Representative Ryan did support a couple of the proposals that we submitted.

NAYLOR: The Energy Center received nearly a quarter-of-a-million dollars in stimulus money, thanks in part to Ryan's efforts. The Wisconsin Energy Conservation Corporation did even better, receiving a $20 million grant for energy-efficiency projects.

There have been other occasions where Ryan has acted for his constituents in ways that might not please the most ardent Tea Party supporters. He voted for the auto industry bailout, which Mitt Romney opposed. Ryan's hometown, Janesville, was home to a since-shuttered GM plant. He also voted for the TARP legislation to rescue the financial industry, saying during House debate that though it violated his principles, it was necessary to prevent a banking crisis.

(SOUNDBITE OF SPEECH)

RYAN: Why does that matter to us? Why does that matter to Janesville, Wisconsin? If it goes the way it could go, that means credit shuts down. Businesses can't get money to pay their payroll to pay their employees. Students can't get student loans for next semester. People can't get car loans. Seniors may not have access to their savings.

NAYLOR: Ryan has also worked for his 1st district constituents in less public ways. John Beckord, president of Janesville Forward, an economic development group, says Ryan only has to be asked and he'll pick up the phone to help recruit a new company to the area.

JOHN BECKORD: A call from Paul Ryan to the CEO of that company is, I think, most often accepted. And Paul, at the very least, can encourage that CEO to at least take a look.

NAYLOR: Beckord says Ryan helped Janesville land Shine Medical Technologies, a company that makes radioactive isotopes used to treat melanomas, and which is receiving a multimillion-dollar federal grant. Still, some in Janesville wish Ryan would do more. Earlier in his congressional career, Ryan delivered more than $5 million in earmarks to his district, according to Taxpayers for Common Sense. Ryan has since renounced the use of earmarks, though Beckord says not everyone agrees.

BECKORD: There are people in the community who wish someone with the stature of Congressman Ryan might help us get some earmarks for this or that.

NAYLOR: But, on the other hand, Beckord says, Ryan has now convinced many in the 1st district that, as Beckord puts it, business as usual when it comes to earmarks is not a plan for the future.

Brian Naylor, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.