Romney Energy Plan Touts Oil, Gas, Coal Production

Aug 23, 2012
Originally published on August 23, 2012 7:07 pm

Mitt Romney outlined an energy plan Thursday that would guide his Republican presidency. It focuses heavily on expanding the supply of fossil fuels. The presumptive nominee said the U.S., Mexico and Canada together could reach energy independence by 2020.

But the plan makes no mention of climate change and would end subsidies for cleaner sources of energy, such as wind and solar.

Romney unveiled the energy plan at a campaign stop in New Mexico, where he fought the wind as he showed flip charts of his policy. That was wind's major appearance in a speech that was overwhelmingly about fossil fuels.

The plan would open up oil and gas development off the Atlantic Coast, as well as the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. And he proposed putting states in charge of regulating oil and gas development on federal lands.

"Three million jobs come back to this country, by taking advantage of something we have right underneath our feet," Romney said. "That's oil and gas and coal. We're going to make it happen; we're going to create those jobs."

The Romney energy plan, laid out in a 21-page white paper, relies heavily on creating deeper partnerships with Mexico and Canada. Mexico could use technical help to reverse its declining oil production, he said, and "Canada has oil sands. We're going to take advantage of those, and build that Keystone pipeline and work with Canada to make sure we have advantage of their great energy sources."

All told, that would dramatically boost oil and gas production, the candidate said.

"I will set a national goal of ... North American energy independence by 2020."

The Romney white paper cites a study by Citibank showing that is possible — provided there are sharp efforts to reduce energy demand. But energy conservation is not part of the Romney plan.

Energy independence is often cited as a way to be free of price fluctuations caused by conflicts in oil-rich regions. But that wouldn't actually lock in stable oil prices.

"Last year, when civil war broke out in Libya and oil markets were deeply disrupted, the price of oil from Canada went up by more in percentage terms than oil from the Middle East," says Michael Levi from the Council on Foreign Relations in New York.

Prices are driven by the global market, regardless of where the U.S. buys the oil from, because if the world price skyrockets, trading partners would cash in on that. Overall, Levi praises some of the fossil fuel proposals in the Romney plan, though he says it addresses only part of the energy picture.

"The word climate does not appear in the energy plan. That is a conspicuous absence," Levi says.

You can't deal with climate change without finding ways to reduce burning fossil fuels, and that's not in the Romney plan. Indeed, the Republican says he does not want to continue subsidizing wind and solar energy, which are clean supplies of energy.

That drew a rebuke from the White House.

"While the Republican approach denigrates forms of energy like wind, this president believes that investing in renewable energy is essential to enhancing our energy independence," said spokesman Jay Carney.

In his energy speech, Romney framed the matter quite differently.

"Sometimes, I have the impression that the whole regulatory attitude of the administration is trying to stop oil and gas and coal," Romney said. "That they don't want those sources, that instead they want to get those things so expensive and so rare that wind and solar become highly cost effective and efficient."

Romney said he likes wind and solar "as much as the next person," but those technologies should rise or fall simply on their economic merits.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

I'm Audie Cornish. And we begin this hour with the politics of energy. Mitt Romney says that in just eight years, the U.S., Mexico and Canada together could reach energy independence. The presumptive Republican nominee today outlined an energy plan that would guide his presidency. It focuses heavily on expanding the supply of fossil fuels. As NPR's Richard Harris reports, it also makes no mention of climate change and would end subsidies for cleaner sources of energy, such as wind and solar.

RICHARD HARRIS, BYLINE: Mr. Romney unveiled the energy plan at a campaign stop in New Mexico, where he fought the wind as he showed flip charts of his policy.

MITT ROMNEY: This is a real achievable objective and I have a chart that still, despite the wind, is still holding up up here. These guys have held it up with about every piece of weight you can think of.

HARRIS: That was wind's major appearance in a speech that was overwhelmingly about fossil fuels. The plan would open up oil and gas development off the Atlantic coast as well as the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. And he proposed putting states in charge of regulating oil and gas development on federal lands to speed its development.

All told, he said the plan would sharply increase domestic production as well as jobs.

ROMNEY: Three million jobs come back to this country by taking advantage of something we have right underneath our feet. That's oil and gas and coal. We're gonna make it happen. We're gonna create those jobs.

HARRIS: The Romney energy plan, laid out in a 21-page white paper, relies heavily on creating partnerships with Mexico and Canada. Mexico could use technical help to reverse its declining oil production, he said. As for Canada...

ROMNEY: Canada has oil sands. We're gonna take advantage of those and build that Keystone pipeline and work with Canada to make sure we have advantage of their great energy sources.

HARRIS: All told, that would dramatically boost oil and gas production, the candidate said.

ROMNEY: I will set a national goal of America and North America, North American energy independence by 2020.

HARRIS: The Romney white paper cites a study by Citibank showing that's possible, provided there are sharp efforts to reduce energy demand. But energy conservation is not part of the Romney plan. Energy independence is often cited as a way to be free of price fluctuations caused by conflicts in oil rich regions. But Michael Levi from the Council on Foreign Relations says that wouldn't actually lock in stable oil prices.

MICHAEL LEVI: Last year, when civil war broke out in Libya and oil markets were deeply disrupted, the price of oil from Canada went up by more in percentage terms than the price of oil from the Middle East.

HARRIS: Prices are driven by the global market, regardless of where we buy the oil from because if the world price skyrockets, our trading partners would cash in on that. Overall, Levi praises some of the fossil fuel proposals in the Romney plan, though he says it only addresses part of the energy picture.

LEVI: The word climate does not appear in the energy plan. That is a conspicuous absence.

HARRIS: You can't deal with climate change without finding ways to reduce burning fossil fuels and that's not in the Romney plan. Indeed, the Republican says he does not want to continue subsidizing wind and solar energy, which are clean supplies of energy. That drew a rebuke from White House spokesman, Jay Carney.

JAY CARNEY: While the Republican approach denigrates forms of energy like wind, this president believes that investing in renewable energy is essential to enhancing our energy independence.

HARRIS: In his energy speech, Romney framed the matter quite differently.

ROMNEY: Sometimes I have the impression that the whole regulatory attitude of the administration is trying to stop oil and gas and coal, that they don't want those sources, that instead they want to get those things so expensive and so rare that wind and solar become highly cost effective and efficient.

HARRIS: Romney says he likes wind and solar as much as the next person, but those technologies should rise or fall simply on their economic merits. Richard Harris, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.