A Portrait Of Chinese Corruption, In Rosy Pink

Jun 29, 2012
Originally published on June 29, 2012 10:26 pm

Corruption is usually thought to be a bad thing. But in China, the answer is no longer crystal clear.

For decades, the country's Communist Party has declared that corruption threatens its very survival. But there are signs that this is changing. Recently, the state-run media have begun arguing that corruption can't be stamped out, so it should be contained to acceptable levels. And some corruption appears to be tacitly condoned.

At an artist's studio in Beijing, dozens of pink-tinted portraits hang in neat lines: beaming men in ties and glasses, the very picture of the archetypal Communist apparatchik. Their portraits are painted rosy pink — the color of money, or at least China's 100-yuan bill.

Hidden But Well-Known Rule

The collection of paintings is called the Hall of Fame. But in fact it's a wall of shame: Each is a Chinese official found guilty of corruption.

The gallery of rogues is the brainchild of artist and filmmaker Zhang Bingjian. So far, he has commissioned 1,600 portraits of corrupt Chinese cadres.

"This is the beauty of the piece," he says. "It's open-ended. You don't know when it will be finished. Probably 10,000, 100,000, who knows? ... There are many new famous people coming every day."

As is fitting for the workshop of the world, Zhang commissions other artists to paint the pink-tinted portraits cheaply, some of them more skillfully than others. Paradoxically, the cumulative effect of tier upon tier of faces is a sort of faceless assembly line of corruption.

"If you want to do business here, even if you want to find a good school for your kids, you have to corrupt somebody," says Zhang. "If you want to find a good hospital for your mother, you have to give money to somebody under the table. ... It's like a hidden rule."

The Chinese public hears headlines about fighting corruption every day, and a new four-book series extolling the morality of government officials has just been issued as a new plank in the fight against graft.

But in fact, official figures from the National Bureau of Statistics show fewer corruption investigations than a decade ago. In 2010 — the last year for which figures are publicly available — just 3,603 people were investigated for the misappropriation of public funds by the Chinese procurator's office, compared with 11,068 people investigated on the same charge 10 years earlier. The number of corruption investigations by the procurator's office has declined by 26 percent over the decade.

Measuring Corruption

An official People's Bank of China report posted online last year, then hastily deleted, estimated that around $125 billion had been stashed overseas since the mid-1990s, by at least 16,000 officials, who had subsequently fled overseas.

Beijing's Tsinghua University has an Anti-Corruption and Governance Research Center. Since August 2009, it has developed a China Corruption Measurement Index. But requests for an interview on the subject were turned down by the professor in charge, Cheng Wenhao, due to the "sensitivity" of the topic.

"It's corruption of the worst kind," says Minxin Pei, professor of government at Claremont McKenna College in California, who says the corruption has become collective and collusive in nature. "In academic jargon, we call this 'looting.' "

A few years ago, Pei made a very rough estimate of the cost of corruption in China, conservatively speaking, putting it at about 3 percent of GDP — in line with a 2004 World Bank study about levels of corruption worldwide.

In a $7 trillion economy like China's, Pei says that would amount to more than $200 billion of wealth stolen every year.

"As long as the economy keeps growing, it may be able to finance the cost of corruption," Pei says. "The real challenge is when the economy slows down, then corruption becomes a real drain on society."

There are signs that the economy is cooling now, with growth for the first quarter of 2012 slowing to 8.1 percent, the slackest pace in three years.

Choosing 'A Lesser Evil'?

But the state-run media now appears to be sending mixed messages on corruption. An editorial published in May in the Global Times argued that stamping out corruption would send the whole country into "pain and confusion." This caused a firestorm online, after being posted under the headline "China Must Permit Moderate Corruption, the Public Should Understand," which was criticized as "misleading" and "malicious" by Hu Xijin, the paper's editor-in-chief.

However, the editorial did note: "There is no way in any country to 'root out' corruption. Most critical is containing it to a level acceptable to the public. And to do this is, for China, especially difficult."

It was followed last week by a People's Daily editorial, which labeled it "extremist" to criticize China just because corruption exists.

"Now the party probably thinks corruption is less of a threat than losing legitimacy by exposing how corrupt this government is," Pei says. "In other words, it has to choose a lesser evil."

China touts a harmonious society, but growing online anger at corruption is souring that harmony. Among retirees having their daily sing-a-long session in a Beijing park, however, there's surprising tolerance toward corruption, which is seen as a fact of life.

"No matter which dynasty, these problems have always happened," says singer Xu Yonghua. "You have to look at this fairly, not judging it with hate."

The Upside To Corruption

According to Pei, government statistics show only 3 percent of officials investigated by the Communist Party's anti-graft watchdog are handed over to the judicial authorities. So, only a tiny minority are punished. And while there is discussion about corruption, artist Zhang Bingjian can't find anywhere to show his work.

"I tried to contact galleries, museum, no response. People get scared, even me, you know. It's understandable. Timing is not right to show this piece," Zhang says. "Fortunately we get Internet. People will start to know that."

But Zhang has already been ordered to take his pictures down from his blog. Despite this, he says, his Hall of Fame shouldn't be seen as an indictment of China. The fact that these cases are made public, he believes, makes this a work not of desperation but of hope.

"Before, we were cheated without knowing," he says. "Now, we know we are cheated. This is the progress we made."

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

Corruption is usually considered a bad thing, but in China, the official view is becoming more murky. For decades, the communist party said corruption threatened its survival, but recently, a state-run paper argued corruption couldn't be stamped out, so it should be contained at acceptable levels.

From Beijing, NPR's Louisa Lim explains.

LOUISA LIM, BYLINE: It's called the hall of fame, but actually, it's a wall of shame. Dozens of pink-tinted portraits hang in neat lines, beaming men in ties and glasses, the very picture of the archetypal communist apparatchik. Their portraits are painted rosy pink, the color of money, or at least China's 100 yuan bill. Each is a real life Chinese official found guilty of corruption.

ZHANG BINGJIAN: (Unintelligible) from Shanghai here.

LIM: And he got 18 years in prison?

BINGJIAN: This is another guy from (unintelligible)...

LIM: This gallery of rogues is the brainchild of artist and filmmaker, Zhang Bingjian. So far, he's commissioned 1,600 portraits of corrupt Chinese officials. As is fitting for the workshop of the world, he employs other artists to paint them cheaply, some better than others.

Paradoxically, the cumulative effect of tier upon tier of faces is a sort of faceless assembly line of corruption. Artist Zhang says corruption permeates every aspect of life in China.

BINGJIAN: If you want to do business here, if you want to find a good school for your kids, you have to corrupt somebody. I mean, if you want to find a good hospital for your mother, you have to give money to somebody under the table. In China, we call it (foreign language spoken). It's like a hidden rule.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN 1: Got the first verdict in China's football corruption scandal that...

UNIDENTIFIED MAN 2: China's ruling communist party has expelled a former railway minister.

LIM: The Chinese public hears headlines about fighting corruption every day, but in fact, official figures show fewer corruption investigations than a decade ago. In 2010, the number of people investigated for misappropriation of public funds was a third the number 10 years before.

An official report posted online last year, then quickly deleted, estimated $120 billion has been stashed overseas since the mid-'90s. Analysts say the corruption has become collective and collusive in nature.

MINXIN PEI: It's corruption of the worst kind. In academic jargon, we call this looting.

LIM: Minxin Pei is professor of government at Claremont McKenna College in California. He estimates the cost of corruption in China, conservatively speaking, to be about three percent of GDP.

PEI: China is a $7 trillion economy. That's $201 billion of wealth stolen each year. As long as the economy keeps growing, it may be able to finance the cost of corruption. The real challenge is when the economy slows down or is not doing as well, then corruption becomes a real drain on society.

LIM: There are signs the economy is slowing now, but the state-run media appears to be sending mixed messages on corruption. An editorial in the Global Times argued stamping out corruption would send the whole country into pain and confusion. A People's Daily piece labeled it extremist to criticize China just because of corruption. Pei has his own theory why.

PEI: Now, the party probably thinks that corruption is less of a threat than losing legitimacy by exposing how corrupt this government is. In other words, it has to choose a lesser evil.

(SOUNDBITE OF SINGING)

LIM: China touts a harmonious society, but growing online anger at corruption is souring that harmony. However, among retirees having their daily sing-song in a Beijing park, there's surprising tolerance towards corruption, which is seen as a fact of life.

XU YONGHUA: (Foreign language spoken).

LIM: No matter which dynasty, these problems have always happened, says singer Xu Yonghua. You have to look at this fairly, not judging it with hate.

According to Pei, official statistics show only three percent of officials investigated are handed over to the judicial authorities, so only a tiny minority are punished. And, while there is discussion about corruption, artist Zhang can't find anywhere to show his work.

BINGJIAN: I tried to contact some gallery, museums, but I had no response. People get scared. Even me, you know, it's understandable. Probably the timing is not right to show this piece. Fortunately, now we got Internet, so people will start to know that.

LIM: But he's already been ordered to take his pictures down from his blog. Despite this, Zhang says, his wall of fame shouldn't be seen as an indictment of China. The fact these cases are made public, he believes, makes this a work not of desperation but of hope.

BINGJIAN: Before, we were cheated without know. Now, we know we are cheated. This is the progress we made.

LIM: Louisa Lim, NPR News, Beijing. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.