New Survey Takes A Snapshot Of The View From Black America

Jun 4, 2013
Originally published on June 6, 2013 5:19 pm

You might think African-Americans might be more pessimistic about their lives. The housing crisis decimated pockets of black wealth. The black unemployment rate has been nearly double the national average for several years.

But according to findings from our survey of more than 1,000 African-Americans, you'd be wrong.

A new poll released Tuesday by NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard School of Public Health found that the overwhelming majority of black people (86 percent) said they were satisfied with their lives. Nearly 60 percent said they would eventually achieve the American dream of financial security and homeownership. A little more than half of those polled (53 percent) said they felt their lives had gotten better in recent years.

The survey sampled about 1,081 people, and the geographic breakdown — with a majority of respondents in the South or in urban areas — roughly matched the demographics of African-Americans in the country more broadly. It asked respondents for their opinions on a wide range of issues: finances, personal health, dating lives, assessments of their communities and neighborhoods, and much more.

Robert Blendon, a professor of public health at Harvard and one of the study's co-directors, said polls usually find that people's reports of their life satisfaction is much higher than the economic climate might indicate. This optimism has barely budged from Harvard's last poll of African-Americans in 2002, when 90 percent of black people said they were satisfied with their lives.

Twenty-one percent said they had achieved the American dream of having a nice home and financial security, while nearly 60 percent said they had not but felt they would eventually. (Sixteen percent said they felt they would never achieve it.)

But Blendon said that beneath that optimism, there's real anxiety. Respondents are "satisfied with their lives, but there's a lot of concern," he said. "They're very fearful of losing their jobs and very fearful of getting stuck with a very large medical bill if they get sick."

A Stark Divide On Financial Stability

When the poll respondents were asked how they felt about their financial lives, there was a clean break right down the middle — about half rated their financial situation as "good" or "excellent," while half said their situation was "not good" or "poor." (This question was about what people thought of their financial conditions, and not about their actual income or personal wealth.)

The way a given person answered this question correlated with big differences in how he or she answered a bunch of other questions. "Just that one split leaves people with very different life experiences," Blendon said.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, that break tracked with differences in the way people felt about things like the schools nearby, their police departments, the cleanliness of their streets, safety from crime and the availability of fresh produce.

"People view their lives in very complex ways; it's not just one-dimensional," Blendon said. Even respondents who said crime in their area was a significant problem for them didn't necessarily feel unhappy with where they lived. (Asked the open-ended question, "What is the biggest issue facing the area where you live?" respondents listed crime above every other concern.)

All The Single Fellas?

One of the most surprising findings in the study: who was or wasn't looking for a romantic partner. When people in the prime marrying cohort — ages 18 to 49, never married, divorced or widowed — were asked whether they were seeking a long-term relationship, just about a third said they were.

But it's the gender breakdown of the relationship numbers that really jumps out: Men were much more likely to say they were looking for a long-term relationship (43 percent) than were women (25 percent).

Blendon speculated that this, too, might be tied in part to economic concerns. He pointed to studies in which black women are more concerned with the financial stability of their partners than Latinas or white women. And because black women are outpacing black men on a host of metrics that might determine their financial prospects — black women are more likely to attend and graduate college and receive advanced degrees — Blendon says they may be less likely to see much financial upside in pairing up, compared with black men. "African-American women appear to have more security than men, and so women [might] see less men who bring financial security to the table," he said.

(An important note here: The pollsters asked people their feelings about entering long-term relationships — not marriage.)

Health Care Concerns

In general, African-Americans were much more satisfied with their health care options than they were a decade ago. When Harvard did its last large poll of black people in 2002, only about a quarter of them said they were "very satisfied" with their health care options. But this year's number showed that the approval numbers nearly doubled, to 47 percent. Indeed, two-thirds said they felt that the last time either they or a family member fell ill, they were treated by one of the best doctors in the area.

Those numbers might be surprising: Government figures from 2011 show that one in five African-Americans was uninsured. But when asked about getting medical care over the past 12 months, the number of people who said they or a family member couldn't get medical care was about 1 in 8 — down from the 1-in-5 figure reported to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation in 2006.

But while there was improvement in access, there were still areas of concern that hadn't budged. Twenty percent of respondents listed high blood pressure and stroke as the biggest health problems in their families, while 19 percent cited diabetes.

The 'Popcorn Desert'?

Another big surprise? The thing folks rated worse than their local schools or police departments or health care — lower than anything else they were asked to rate — was the quality of local entertainment venues like movie theaters and nightclubs. While neighborhoods with a paucity of food options are often described as "food deserts," respondents gave their grocery stores relatively high grades.

We wondered whether the harsh ratings given to entertainment venues might be a symptom of "popcorn deserts" in black neighborhoods, but we found no significant differences in these ratings when broken out by the racial makeup of the respondent's area. This was one of the few areas where the pollsters didn't see a split depending on the respondent's financial self-assessment. Whether they said they were in strong or shaky financial shape, respondents were most likely to offer up C, D or F grades to their entertainment venues.

Additional Findings

  • About half of those polled said they lived in an area that was all or mostly black, and a plurality (44 percent) described themselves as middle class.
  • About 93 percent of respondents said religion was either the most important part of their lives (33 percent), a very important part (45 percent) or a somewhat important part (15 percent).
  • Nearly equal numbers said that all or most of the people who lived in their area were black (47 percent) and that some or just a few black people lived in their areas (51 percent).
  • Thirty-six percent of respondents said they had experienced a few types of negative encounters with others at least a few times a year — being threatened or harassed, being treated as if they weren't smart, receiving poorer service at restaurants or stores, having people act afraid of them, or being treated with less courtesy or respect than others — and that they felt like that experience could be attributed to race.

In the coming days, we'll be diving deeper into these results. (Check back later today for the full PDF featuring topline findings from the report.) We'll be updating this post with links to some of the stories based on this poll as they come online. We want to hear what you think of the poll.

And to our black Code Switcher readers: Do these findings ring true to your experiences? What in the poll surprised you?

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

LINDA WERTHEIMER, HOST:

This is MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm Linda Wertheimer.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

And I'm Renee Montagne.

This morning, NPR is starting a new series, The View from Black America. We'll be examining African-Americans' perceptions of many aspects of their lives. The series is based on a new poll being released this morning by NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard School of Public Health.

Joining us to talk more about the poll's findings is Gene Demby. He's the lead blogger for NPR's Code Switch Team, which covers race, ethnicity and culture.

Good morning.

GENE DEMBY, BYLINE: Good morning, Renee.

MONTAGNE: Why don't you begin by describing for us who was polled, where they live and, very broadly, what they were asked about?

DEMBY: So the poll's respondents were pretty representative of the black American population, more broadly. About 60 percent lived in the South, about 60 percent lived in urban areas - obviously there's a lot of overlap there, there's urban areas in the South. And they were asked questions about their finances, their families, their health, their relationships and a bunch of other questions.

MONTAGNE: So just about anything you could think of to say how do you feel and what do you think.

DEMBY: Yeah, pretty much.

MONTAGNE: What were the most surprising answers to the poll?

DEMBY: What we were initially surprised by was the high levels of life satisfaction that hadn't really dipped since Harvard's last poll of African-Americans way back in 2002. Of course, since then, we've come in and out of a recession and the housing crisis, and the ongoing economic climate - all of which have kind of buffeted black families and black people.

But despite all of that, just like in 2002, about 9 in 10 respondents reported being satisfied with their lives. And about 6 in 10 said they were optimistic that they would achieve the American dream.

MONTAGNE: Which is interesting, because one would think that a group doing less well financially would be more pessimistic, generally speaking.

DEMBY: Right, and our partners at Harvard said that, you know, Americans in general tend to be more satisfied with their lives than the economic situation in the country as a whole. But when we dive into the numbers, there's a really stark divide there. Here's how Robert Blendon of Harvard describes what he found.

ROBERT BLENDON: Half put themselves in better financial shape and half less. And it so determines their views about how other things are going in their lives. That was a big surprise to us.

DEMBY: That break on finances was, again, right down the middle - essentially 50/50. And this was perception. This how people thought they were doing. And that perception determined the way you felt about crime, and pollution, and your city services - any number of things. Interestingly one of the only things that wasn't impacted by how you felt on this question was the entertainment options available to you - those things stayed the same.

MONTAGNE: And stayed the same, good or bad?

DEMBY: Stayed the same, bad.

MONTAGNE: Oh, all right. Well, what about more personal matters? What did you learn about family life, say, or dating prospects? Any surprises there?

DEMBY: By and large, the single respondents in prime marrying age - that's 18 to 49; people were divorced or widowed or have never married. They weren't really so pressed to find a mate. In fact, only about a third of those people were looking.

But what really jumped out to us was the gender split among those single respondents. It was men who were way more likely to say that they were looking for a long-term committed relationship. About 43 percent of men said they were looking for one, while only a quarter of women did.

MONTAGNE: Well, that's not the message we so often get from women's magazine covers and certainly relationship advice books about men and women, or even songs.

DEMBY: Yeah, it's not like Beyonce was, you know, calling for solidarity with other single fellows, right? I mean...

MONTAGNE: No, put a ring on it, boys.

(LAUGHTER)

DEMBY: But anecdotally, we encountered a lot of skepticism about that response and when we discussed that with our colleagues. A lot of people wondered how that could possibly be.

MONTAGNE: And what did you figure out might explain it?

DEMBY: So, here again, people's finances might have played a big part in the way they answered this question. Robert Blendon, who we just heard from a second ago, said that there were a lot of previous studies found that showed that black women were more sensitive to the financial stability of their partners, than Latinas or white women. And since black women are outpacing black men on metrics like college education and postgraduate degrees, that gap might be explained in part by black women weighing the financial pros and cons of getting paired up and finding that prospect kind of wanting.

MONTAGNE: I gather also that the poll found the overwhelming majority of African-Americans want their children to go to college. Big, big deal.

DEMBY: Yeah, nine out of 10 want their children to go to college. And almost half of those who say they do want their kids to also get advanced degrees. So that runs a little bit against a narrative that black people don't value education, 'cause when we ask them, they clearly do. And it underscores, again, the optimism that so many people reported despite what's happening in the economy.

MONTAGNE: And later today on ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, we'll hear more about what the poll reveals about relationships in the black community.

Gene Demby is the lead blogger for Code Switch, which again, you can find at npr.org/codeswitch. And Gene, thanks very much for joining us.

DEMBY: Thank you for having me, Renee. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.